• Keeping Friends

Owning Up To A Mistake in Judgment

Published: April 2, 2024 | By | Reply Continue Reading

Anyone can make a mistake in judgment, but it’s reasonable to expect a good friend to own up to her mistake.


Dear Irene:

About eight months ago, I had my heart broken by my best friend of three years.

Liz and a guy I had been dating for a short time slept together after they had been drinking excessively. Liz and the guy, Dave, had been friends since high school, and she was the one who set me up with him. However, this particular night, she told me she was lonely and was going to have sex with him – I didn’t believe her. When I found out, I felt devastated and betrayed by them both.

Dave apologized repeatedly. We are no longer dating, and I was able to forgive him.

On the other hand, Liz hasn’t even apologized once for her mistake in judgment and refuses to take responsibility for her part in what happened. She blames Dave completely and says he took advantage of her.

She and I have had many talks, but her story doesn’t add up, especially since she said she intended to sleep with him that night.

Whenever I speak to Dave or mention something about him, she makes me feel SO guilty for talking to him “after what he did to her.” Our mutual friends think she is blaming him, so she doesn’t have to admit she did something wrong and hurtful to me.

Since this happened, I have become a jealous, self-conscious, mistrusting person with friends and boyfriends. I began self-medicating with alcohol and got into bad situations. She blamed me for anything bad that happened instead of seeing that I was in pain. In her eyes, we are still best friends. We have even discussed moving out of state together. However, I still don’t forgive her or trust her.

I want an apology. I want to stop feeling manipulated, self-conscious, and depressed. I will always love her and don’t want to hurt her, but being friends with her is hurting ME.

Why haven’t I been able to move past this after eight months? Is there any chance our friendship can be saved? How can I talk about this with her without feeling guilty and manipulated?



Dear Hayley,

If Liz hasn’t taken responsibility for her actions and mistake in judgment after eight months, she is unlikely to apologize soon.

Adding insult to injury, she has positioned herself, rather than you, in the role of the victim. YOU were the one who was betrayed by your two friends. Liz may believe you are still best friends simply because you’ve taken no steps to make her think otherwise.

Sometimes, people believe they need to obtain closure from another person before they sever a friendship. This isn’t true.

Be forthright and open. Express your anger and disappointment in Liz’s behavior and move on. Follow up your words with actions. This will give you a sense of closure.

Liz lacks the empathy and insight you would expect from a good friend. You will continue to feel bad about yourself if you continue this toxic friendship in the hopes that Liz will change.

Hope this helps.



Tags: , , , , , , ,


Leave a Reply